Medicare Coverage Options Comparison
Understanding Your Medicare Options
Choosing the right Medicare coverage is one of the most important healthcare decisions you'll make. With several options available—Original Medicare (Parts A & B), Medicare Advantage (Part C), Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans, and Prescription Drug Plans (Part D)—it's essential to understand how each works and what fits your unique situation. Your choice will affect not only your out-of-pocket costs but also which doctors you can see, what services are covered, and how you access your healthcare benefits.
The comparison table below outlines the key advantages and disadvantages of each Medicare option. Take time to consider factors like your current health status, preferred doctors and hospitals, prescription medication needs, travel habits, and budget. Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all solution—the "best" plan is the one that aligns with your personal healthcare needs and financial situation.
Doctor Choice
Consider which providers you want to see and network requirements
Medications
Review your prescription needs and drug coverage options
Budget
Compare premiums, deductibles, and out-of-pocket costs
Travel
Evaluate coverage when you're away from home
Need personalized guidance? If you have questions about which option might work best for you, I'm here to help you navigate these choices with honest, unbiased guidance.
Toll Free: (888) 588-5175
| Feature / Benefit | Original Medicare (Parts A & B) |
Medicare Advantage (Part C) |
Medigap (Supplement Insurance) |
Prescription Drug Plan (Part D) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who Provides It | Federal government | Private insurance companies (approved by Medicare) | Private insurance companies | Private insurance companies |
| Enrollment | Automatic at 65 (if receiving Social Security) or manual | Voluntary during enrollment periods | Optional add-on to Original Medicare | Optional add-on to Original Medicare or some MA plans |
| Coverage Type | Hospital (Part A) + Medical (Part B) | Combines A, B, and usually D | Helps pay A & B out-of-pocket costs | Prescription drug coverage |
| Doctor & Hospital Choice | Any provider that accepts Medicare nationwide | Must use in-network providers (HMO/PPO rules) | Follows Original Medicare (any provider nationwide) | Use plan's pharmacy network |
| Referrals / Networks | No referrals; no network limits | Usually required for HMOs; optional for PPOs | No network limits | Must use network pharmacies |
| Prescription Drug Coverage | Not included | Usually included (MAPD plans) | Not included | Included |
| Out-of-Pocket Costs | 20% coinsurance + deductibles + no out-of-pocket limit | Copays, coinsurance, and annual maximum out-of-pocket limit (MOOP) | Covers many or all of Original Medicare's gaps | Monthly premium + drug copays/coinsurance |
| Premiums | Part B premium (and Part A if no work credits) | Part B premium + plan premium (if applicable) | Part B premium + Medigap premium | Part D premium |
| Extra Benefits (Vision, Dental, Hearing, Fitness, etc.) |
Not covered | Commonly included | Not covered | Not covered |
| Travel Coverage (Outside U.S.) |
Very limited | Limited (some emergency coverage) | Some plans offer limited emergency coverage abroad | Not applicable |
| Flexibility | High – any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare | Moderate – limited by plan's network | High – any doctor that accepts Medicare | Moderate – must use in-network pharmacies |
| Maximum Out-of-Pocket Limit | None | Yes (set annually by CMS, varies by plan) | None (but covers most costs) | Varies by plan |
| Supplemental Options | Can add Medigap and/or Part D | Cannot combine with Medigap | Works only with Original Medicare | Works with Original Medicare or MA (if not included) |
| Paperwork / Claims | You or your provider file claims with Medicare | Simplified – plan handles all claims | Medigap coordinates automatically with Medicare | Handled by plan |
| Best For | Those wanting nationwide access and flexibility | Those who want all-in-one convenience and extras | Those who want predictable costs and nationwide access | Those who need standalone prescription coverage |
Original Medicare (Parts A & B)
Who Provides It
Federal government
Enrollment
Automatic at 65 (if receiving Social Security) or manual
Coverage Type
Hospital (Part A) + Medical (Part B)
Doctor & Hospital Choice
Any provider that accepts Medicare nationwide
Referrals / Networks
No referrals; no network limits
Prescription Drug Coverage
Not included
Out-of-Pocket Costs
20% coinsurance + deductibles + no out-of-pocket limit
Premiums
Part B premium (and Part A if no work credits)
Extra Benefits (Vision, Dental, Hearing, Fitness, etc.)
Not covered
Travel Coverage (Outside U.S.)
Very limited
Flexibility
High – any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare
Maximum Out-of-Pocket Limit
None
Supplemental Options
Can add Medigap and/or Part D
Paperwork / Claims
You or your provider file claims with Medicare
Best For
Those wanting nationwide access and flexibility
Medicare Advantage (Part C)
Who Provides It
Private insurance companies (approved by Medicare)
Enrollment
Voluntary during enrollment periods
Coverage Type
Combines A, B, and usually D
Doctor & Hospital Choice
Must use in-network providers (HMO/PPO rules)
Referrals / Networks
Usually required for HMOs; optional for PPOs
Prescription Drug Coverage
Usually included (MAPD plans)
Out-of-Pocket Costs
Copays, coinsurance, and annual maximum out-of-pocket limit (MOOP)
Premiums
Part B premium + plan premium (if applicable)
Extra Benefits (Vision, Dental, Hearing, Fitness, etc.)
Commonly included
Travel Coverage (Outside U.S.)
Limited (some emergency coverage)
Flexibility
Moderate – limited by plan's network
Maximum Out-of-Pocket Limit
Yes (set annually by CMS, varies by plan)
Supplemental Options
Cannot combine with Medigap
Paperwork / Claims
Simplified – plan handles all claims
Best For
Those who want all-in-one convenience and extras
Medigap (Supplement Insurance)
Who Provides It
Private insurance companies
Enrollment
Optional add-on to Original Medicare
Coverage Type
Helps pay A & B out-of-pocket costs
Doctor & Hospital Choice
Follows Original Medicare (any provider nationwide)
Referrals / Networks
No network limits
Prescription Drug Coverage
Not included
Out-of-Pocket Costs
Covers many or all of Original Medicare's gaps
Premiums
Part B premium + Medigap premium
Extra Benefits (Vision, Dental, Hearing, Fitness, etc.)
Not covered
Travel Coverage (Outside U.S.)
Some plans offer limited emergency coverage abroad
Flexibility
High – any doctor that accepts Medicare
Maximum Out-of-Pocket Limit
None (but covers most costs)
Supplemental Options
Works only with Original Medicare
Paperwork / Claims
Medigap coordinates automatically with Medicare
Best For
Those who want predictable costs and nationwide access
Prescription Drug Plan (Part D)
Who Provides It
Private insurance companies
Enrollment
Optional add-on to Original Medicare or some MA plans
Coverage Type
Prescription drug coverage
Doctor & Hospital Choice
Use plan's pharmacy network
Referrals / Networks
Must use network pharmacies
Prescription Drug Coverage
Included
Out-of-Pocket Costs
Monthly premium + drug copays/coinsurance
Premiums
Part D premium
Extra Benefits (Vision, Dental, Hearing, Fitness, etc.)
Not covered
Travel Coverage (Outside U.S.)
Not applicable
Flexibility
Moderate – must use in-network pharmacies
Maximum Out-of-Pocket Limit
Varies by plan
Supplemental Options
Works with Original Medicare or MA (if not included)
Paperwork / Claims
Handled by plan
Best For
Those who need standalone prescription coverage
Important: This is a general comparison. Specific plan benefits and costs vary by location and insurance carrier. Consult with a licensed insurance agent for personalized guidance tailored to your individual needs.